

| Objectives | Excellent | Good | Fair | Poor | Incomplete |
| Rolling out a Coil | The coil is even in thickness throughout. | The coil is a little thin or a little thick in a few spots, but does not effect the structural integrity of the vessel | The coil is a little thin or a little thick in many spots, but does not effect the structural integrity of the vessel | The coil is very thin or very thick in a few spots and is hurting the structural integrity of the vessel | The coil is very thin or very thick in many spots and is hurting the structural integrity of the vessel |
| Smoothing | One side has been smoothed out, and there are no cracks along where the coils are. | One side has been smoothed out, but there are cracks along where the coils are. | Most of either the inside or outside of the coil vessel is smoothed out | Part of the inside or outside of the coil vessel is smoothed out | Neither the inside nor outside of the coil vessel is smoothed out |
| Evenness of walls | The walls are of even thickness throughout. The weight of the vessel is distributed evenly | The wall is thicker at one spot. There are a few cracks. The weight of the vessel is distributed evenly. | The wall is thick and thin randomly. There are some cracks. The weight of the vessel is distributed evenly | The wall is thick and thin randomly. There are many cracks. The weight of the vessel is distributed unevenly | The walls of the vessel are nonexistant, or cannot stand by itself. The weight of the vessel is distributed unevenly |
| Structural Integrity (Scoring) | The project stays together in one piece | The project has fallen apart at one or two places | The project has fallen apart at three or more places places | The project has fallen apart at three or more places places. It has trouble standing up | The project has fallen apart at five or more places places. It has no height |
| Glaze Application | The glaze has been applied thick and even throughout the cup | The glaze has been applied thick and even on most the cup. There are one or two unintended spots where the clay is bare | The glaze has been applied thickly on most the cup. There are a few unintended spots where the clay is bare | The glaze has been applied to the cup but it requires a second coat. There are several spots where the clay is bare | The glaze has been applied thin and sloppy. There are several spots where the clay is bare |
